Small sample size, but Shelley>>>>>Huntley

[Italy88]

He is a baller. 

[javadave]

It’s not even close. Huntley may have more physical skills, but Shelley plays smarter and is a gamer. 

[gUrthBrooks]

Shelley is a QB who can go through his read progression and stay poised while doing it.

[UtesRule]

If Shelley wins the next 3 games, including the Rose Bowl, he’s the starter next year. 

[Italy88]

He just looks so much more comfortable and smoothe. 

[Distantute]

You guys are idiots.  Shelley is not even in the same universe in terms of accuracy.  I really like Shelley and said Tuttle would transfer before the season started because he’d lose out to Shelley but Huntley is a lot better than Shelley right now.  

[EagleMountainUte]

Shelley wins a Rose Bowl and you say bench him. 

[Distantute]

If we are in rose bowl Huntley will start.  Let’s not start a debate though and enjoy a chance for the championship.  Go Ducks!!!

[Gregbroncs]

You guys are idiots.  Shelley is not even in the same universe in terms of accuracy.  I really like Shelley and said Tuttle would transfer before the season started because he’d lose out to Shelley but Huntley is a lot better than Shelley right now.  

My response…

In the passing game Shelley has shown more accuracy and more ability to follow his progressions. Huntley brings a lot of athleticism and makes plays out of nothing quite often, but for the passing game Shelley looks better.

[Distantute]

Again, im a big shelley fan, but objectively huntley is the better qb right now.  The completion percentage/accuracy isnt even close.  Shelley was well under 50% today against a non-existent pass rush.  Weve kicked do many field goals the past two weeks.  Very hard to understand how anyone that understands the game thinks shelley is better right now.