Pick Em Week #2 Results Posted! TIEBREAKER POLICY DISCUSSION NEEDED


  • Next: Arizona State – Sat Oct 19 4PM – Pac12 TV
    • #12578
      2

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      Ok I’ve resolved the small issue with the results. You can now view the week #2 leaderboard as well as the season leaderboard. FOUR contestants went 10-0 for the week! Nice going. Week #3 picks are now open.

      TIEBREAKERS

      kentwool prize

      Because there’s a 4 way tie for first and we have one prize to award, we must find a way to do a playoff. I have a couple of ideas, but I’d like to have a discussion between members to get some ideas what to do.

      One idea is to have one game each week which is a guess the score. The person who most closely guesses that wins a playoff. The problem with that is it will take a lot more work to implement, and it won’t be as easy for players to make their picks. It’s not impossible though.

      IDEAS PLEASE, both on deciding this week’s winner and a way to move forward! Thanks.

    • #12587

      FormerUteSax
      Ute Fan
      @formerutesax

      Thunderdome?

      • #12589
        1

        Anonymous

    • #12590

      ironman1315
      Ute Fan
      @ironman1315

      What about one game (Itah?) where the closest to the score wins?

    • #12592
      1 1

      Dugway
      Ute Fan
      @dugway

      I would say whoever responded first to this thread should win. Must be present to win, right???

    • #12593
      1

      89ute
      Ute Fan
      @89ute

      Once conference play starts there will be a lot of ties. With byes most weeks we’re only picking 5 games.

      Total score of the Utah game can be the 1st tie breaker. Since it’s one number it might be an easy thing to program.

      2nd tiebreaker could be total season number of winning picks, which might be easy to manually check given the possible low number of people in a 2nd tiebreaker.

      On Utah’s bye week just designate another game for the tie breaker.

    • #12594
      1

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      Hey @89ute I’ve looked forward in the season to the weeks that there are very few games. I’ve thought of adding a few non pac-12 games as “bonus” games to keep the picks up around 10-12.

      • #12595

        89ute
        Ute Fan
        @89ute

        Would the bonus games be separated from the Pac12 games?

        • #12598

          Tony
          Admin/Founder
          @admin

          Would the bonus games be separated from the Pac12 games?

          Not really. They’re just games that happen to not have Pac-12 teams playing in them. Maybe we could pick a few of the marquee games if we need to fill some spots.

          • #12601

            89ute
            Ute Fan
            @89ute

            Well, … me, like coach Whitt says “goes into the Pac-12 cave” when conference play starts. I rarely watch anything but Pac-12 and get to know the teams pretty well. It might be less popular if it’s Pac-12 only, maybe not? Are you thinking of going beyond the Pac-12 games because of the tiebreaker headache?

            Personally, I like Pac-12 only. Maybe put it in a poll? The whole point is to drive traffic and good discussions. If everybody likes more games over Pac-12 exclusivity, go for it. I prefer getting into the nitty gritty of our conference. Beyond scores and highlights it’s impossible to follow all of college football unless you’re unemployed.

    • #12607

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      I’ll put some thought to the tiebreaker score thing. I’m just short on time lately and that stuff takes a long time to produce.

      • #12613
        1

        89ute
        Ute Fan
        @89ute

        After sleeping on it I’d like to make it known that I’m 100% in support of the Pac 12 pick’em being Pac-12 only.

    • #12615
      1

      leftyjace
      Ute Fan
      @leftyjace

      Here’s an idea. I like the pick the Utah score. But if you don’t want to rely on that…
      How about who ever performed the best the previous week? And if they performed the same… the week before that?
      Kind of a reward for continuous good performance.

      • #12687
        1

        Dugway
        Ute Fan
        @dugway

        Previous week performance sounds good, without <much> additional work for Tony.
        Just a sec…
        <click><click><click>…
        Wait, that’s a horrible idea!

    • #12719

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      Rather than the following week’s performance, I could have the tiebreaker go to the member who is the best participant in the forum.

      • #12747

        Dugway
        Ute Fan
        @dugway

        EXCELLENT idea! Best idea yet, Tony. Look at me be active on the board! Look at my pathetic begging… for a pair of socks? I guess they do look like pretty awesome socks.

    • #12738
      3

      FormerUteSax
      Ute Fan
      @formerutesax

      It’s a pair of socks right? So if it’s a two way tie each person could get one sock 😉

    • #12740

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      Well, we had a 4-way tie… Half a sock each!

    • #12741
      3

      FormerUteSax
      Ute Fan
      @formerutesax

      Maybe they could just take turns with the socks???

    BACK TO TOP

    You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

    Utah Utes Fan Board Forums Utah Utes Sports Pac-12 Pick Em Week #2 Results Posted! TIEBREAKER POLICY DISCUSSION NEEDED

    This topic contains 18 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by  Dugway 3 years, 1 month ago.