Sagarin, S&P+ 9/25/18


Viewing 4 reply threads
    • #69295
      11

      shakeitsugaree
      Ute Fan
      @shakeitsugaree

      Short version: S&P+ says we go 7-2 and win the south; Sagarin says we go 6-3 and SC finishes 7-2.

      One thing I’ve been thinking about this week is how much I like Connelly’s S&P+ metric. There’s been a lot of talk on this site about whether statistics are meaningful or useful in any way. I would recommend reading this explanation of S&P+ (I’ve linked to this before) before you decide to disregard statistics. You can find the S&P+ rankings here. Connelly claims that S&P+ tends to hit between 51 and 54 percent against the Vegas spread. Not bad. BTW, S&P+ says we win this Saturday; this is the difference in whether we take the south, because SC is also predicted to finish 7-2, but we would hold the head to head tiebreaker.

      For a brief version of the long explanation, S&P+ evaluates a team’s performance in what Connelly defines as the Five Factors of winning: efficiency, explosiveness, field position, finishing drives, and turnovers. These factors are weighted to reflect their relative importance in predicting wins; Connelly states in his explanation that efficiency is the single most important stat in creating wins. What is efficiency? It is based on ‘success rate’ which Connelly defines thusly:

      First downs: gaining at least 50 percent of necessary yardage (usually 5 yards) is successful.
      Second downs: gaining at least 70 percent of necessary yardage is successful.
      Third or fourth downs: gaining at least 100 percent of necessary yardage is successful.

      There’s more to S&P+, but in looking at the breakdown in how each team is ranked, this system makes intuitive sense. For example, Utah as the #1 defense as determined by S&P+; Alabama has the #1 offense.

      What do you guys think? Are there better analytics out there that anyone knows about?

    • #69298
      5

      ladyinred
      Ute Fan
      @ladyinred

      I do not know, but thumbs up for this post and especially for use of the word ‘thusly’.

    • #69312

      Duhwayne
      Ute Fan
      @duhwayne

      Yeah me too. Shakeitsugaree sounds like Shakespeare. Or like Star at around 24, where I think we are..

    • #69316
      1

      SkinyUte
      Ute Fan
      @skinyute

      A quick side question. Is your name “shake it sugaree” or “shake its ugaree”.

      Not that either makes any sense to me…just curious.

    • #69338
      1

      UtMtBiker
      Ute Fan
      @utmtbiker

      So…you’re telling me that you can’t count on the “eye test”. The radio guys and Mel Kiper keep talking about the “eye test” so must be solid.  

Viewing 4 reply threads
BACK TO TOP

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Utah Utes Fan Board Forums Utah Utes Sports Football Sagarin, S&P+ 9/25/18