Can we have downvotes (dislikes)?


  • Next: @ BYU – Thu Aug 29 8:15pm – ESPN TV
    • #2517

      AZswayze
      Ute Fan
      @AZswayze

      I only use them on other sites for two purposes, one is when somebody says something just to be an asshole to somebody else (rarely), and two is for the purpose of limiting posts per user. On ufn if somebody gets enough downvotes they are only allowed to post a certain amount of times a day. Works great for combating trolls.

    • #2521

      Anonymous

      This site isn’t utefans.

      Edit:People still feed the trolls and most people get off on it.

      • #2525

        AZswayze
        Ute Fan
        @AZswayze

        No s**t. You have made it quite obvious how much of a stick you have up your ass about utefans. I only used utefans as an example of how well this works for combating trolls.

        EDIT: you missed the point – regardless of whether or not people feed trolls once enough people downvote the person they can no longer post again.

        • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  AZswayze.
        • #2529

          Anonymous

          Or we could be an adult and ignore them?

          • #2531

            AZswayze
            Ute Fan
            @AZswayze

            Sure, let them post as much as they want and clutter the board. Awesome plan. Being an adult is so much better than thinking about how to limit unwanted behavior.

            • #2533

              Anonymous

              I don’t really have a stick it is just whats the point of another Utah fan website if it is identical to utefans? Tired of the comments of lets make it like utefans. I also wouldn’t mind if a moderator just booted that content when people troll. But if people on here choose to feed the trolls let them spend their time as they see fit.

              • #2536

                AZswayze
                Ute Fan
                @AZswayze

                Utefans is an example, I also have used reddit as an example in other threads. They have a downvoting system that moves crappy posts down. You don’t key in on that though. I love this site so far, but there are things that can be improved, and yes utefans does certain things better imho. Doesn’t mean we are making this utefans.

                I personally don’t like the idea of moderators tossing people at their own discretion. Cougarboard does that, and you can’t even speak ill of BYU without immediate action. I like the voting system (beit utefans or reddit), because it gives some power to the members.

                • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  AZswayze.
                • #2541

                  Anonymous

                  The like button for the time being does nothing so first he needs to fix that. I like Utehub because of the content, lets say compared to utefans. A serious response about football with 10 useless comments attached to drive the conversation how the board morons see fit.

                  • #2546

                    AZswayze
                    Ute Fan
                    @AZswayze

                    Did somebody over there bang your wife? Seriously, I understand you don’t like that board, but now you’re just being a dick. You do realize that the vast majority of posters here migrated from ufn, and most of us still post over there yet you continue to denigrate these folks (myself included). If you hated ufn, you will likely end up hating it over here after long enough.

                    • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  AZswayze.
                    • #2551

                      Anonymous

                      You are the one personally attacking and using a tone that is not very polite. Majority of your comments are either critical or make it like Utefans. I don’t like utefans because literally it was a few board posters driving the site, with alternate egos mocking people. If you like that so much stay on that website is all. Lets make it like utefans or reddit just doesn’t fly when you are constantly on here saying get rid of Utah womens basketballs, add politics, add this add this.. blah blah blah. Tony has done a great job ALL BY himself for the most part.

                      • #2563

                        AZswayze
                        Ute Fan
                        @AZswayze

                        Show me one personal attack, I’ve always gone out of my way to steer clear of this. And saying you have a stick up your ass is not a personal attack, although you appear to be incredibly sensitive so maybe it is (and I guess this would be too in your eyes). Also, I’m giving suggestions. I sent a message to tony a few days ago praising him, but he asked for suggestions so I’m giving them. There have been dozens of posts making suggestions, but you’re p**sed because I’ve made some? All of my posts have been critical? Please, the ones you focus on have been, but I’ve made posts in nearly every category so far discussing a wide range of topics.

                        You clearly don’t know what you’re talking about either. I know a ton of people personally on utefans, either as friends or as customers of my business, and they are individual posters who contribute greatly. It’s not “like three posters with a bunch of fake accounts”.

                        • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  AZswayze.
                      • #2567

                        Anonymous

                        Your tone is clearly argumentative. Saying “No s**t” or you have a stick up your ass. Or overly sensitive is all unprofessional. It is about respect, Utefans lacks respect has for a long time. This site has been much better about it.

                      • #2571

                        AZswayze
                        Ute Fan
                        @AZswayze

                        I have taken this tone with you, because a couple of days ago you called ufn a circle jerk with a few idiots with multiple accounts making up all the posts. I responded to that post, but you never said anything else on that thread. Your clear dislike of utefans and its members, of which make up the bulk of folks here, is clear and distasteful. Why in the world would I be respectful towards somebody who acted this way towards myself and other members right from the jump?

                        Also, what in the world does this have to do with professionalism? You’re taking this site, and possibly life in general far too seriously.

                      • #2577

                        Anonymous

                        It is a circle jerk I stand by that statement. I meant no offense other than stating the obvious. It is a broad statement that should not be applied to all of utefans but that is my opinion and I haven’t contributed to that site for awhile.

                        This site how it stands now is great.

                      • #2583

                        AZswayze
                        Ute Fan
                        @AZswayze

                        You meant no offense by saying “it’s just three posters” who are “morons” posting all the content over there? Or by playing into the “beavis and butthead” posts? Sure bud.

                        And the site is great so far, doesn’t mean it can’t be better though. You act as if suggesting something is somehow degrading to tony. Ridiculous.

                        • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  AZswayze.
                      • #2587

                        Anonymous

                        While clearly you mean offense? Bringing up my wife, stick up my ass?

                      • #2590

                        AZswayze
                        Ute Fan
                        @AZswayze

                        Jesus christ, I can see why you don’t like ufn. You are so thin skinned I don’t see how you make it out your front door. Dude, asking if somebody banged your wife in jest is so far from a personal attack or offensive that it’s silly. Calling people morons on the other hand…

                      • #2601

                        Anonymous

                        Maybe you are missing the point. Mine was a statement of fact you are making comments FOR shock value. If someone posts a concern over the Utah offense on this site they get a fairly good answer with some reasonable comments. Not We are fine or I prayed about. The very thing you fear troll behavior DRIVES utefans. Because the clique drives it which alienates many that don’t have the opportunity to clique with them.

                      • #2609

                        AZswayze
                        Ute Fan
                        @AZswayze

                        Get off your f**king high horse. I make comments for shock value? Outside of this dumpster fire of a thread lets look at my posts just from today:

                        I actually like Arizona, but I am rooting against them this season, because I see them as the likely candidate to represent the south in the CCG.

                        Shocking, absolutely shocking.

                        The one thing I don’t like about the running format is that even during wins it’s a non-stop bitchfest. I cannot stand the posters who think they know more than the coaches, especially when it comes to play calling. How in the f**k does somebody grow the balls to question the calls when they have spent ZERO time with the players/personnel, and ZERO time scouting the opposing team or studying film (outside of maybe watching some games)? Once in a while a weird play will come in out of left field that makes you scratch your head, but I’m talking about the guys who sit there the entire game, and rail the OC for every single f**king play. It’s so goddamn exhausting.

                        This is shocking, me being critical of ufn.

                        I’m sure some will take offense to this, but do we really need a separate category here? I have no problem with girl’s basketball, and even watch the lady Utes from time to time, but this area ain’t gonna get much action. Sorry, but figured I’d say it, and if you agree, Tony, it could clean up the board a tad.

                        Oh heavens no, a suggestion. At least it was correct, somebody took offense to it.

                        I grew up playing baseball, and after having daughters softball became the goto sport in our house for many years. I coached for several years, and really grew to love the game. I actually enjoy watching it more than baseball as it’s more fast paced, and the players are far more enthusiastic. Doesn’t hurt that Utah joined a softball power conference right around the same time my girls started playing.
                        We really began rooting for Utah around then, 2010ish, but they were difficult to watch at times. They finished the first season of PAC-12 play with two wins. Fast forward to last season, and oh what a great job Hogue did. She won conference coach of the year honors while guiding Utah to it’s first winning season (conference play), and an NCAA tourney berth. Seems like those years of torment are starting to pay off, and I’m really looking forward to the upcoming season.
                        We lost our best player in Kate Dickman, but her little sis is an incoming freshman this year. Pacheco may be the best defensive catcher in the PAC-12, and while her bat was a liability much of last season she really started to turn it on toward the end. Their bullpen is young and promising as well. Anyway, not too many folks followed the team on ufn, so hoping there are some people here who will contribute over the course of the next year. Go Utes!

                        My god, the horror.

                      • #2618

                        Anonymous

                        Allright p**sing match is done. I truthfully didn’t even read your Women’s basketball thread I saw the header and then you started this one and I thought no more Utefans bulls**t. Just ignore it if you don’t like it I try to say but I fed this post. So I am done I will ignore it and you without any administrative help.

          • #2817

            justaute
            Ute Fan
            @justaute

            Asking sports-fans (people) to be adults…haha. That’s a good one. I do agree with you. People take this $hit way too seriously. Many of us ex-collegiate athletes don’t even take it that far.

        • #2736

          Anonymous

          Wow son, no need to throw a fit.

    • #2524

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      I’ve gone back and forth on downvotes. I like to be “positive” in attitude.

      You bring up a good automatic moderation point which is when someone gets enough downvotes to be moderated.

      • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  Tony.
      • #2544

        Hockeybeard
        Ute Fan
        @hockeybeard

        It could be a system like reddit where if there are enough downvotes, the post gets collapsed so you have to choose to open it – that way its not deleted automatically, and the poster isn’t harmed in the future, its just that one post.

      • #2579

        Wilson’s Mustache
        Ute Fan
        @sigmaute

        I like the down vote idea.

        I understand not wanting to make this exactly like UF.N & clearly that isn’t going to be the case, but why reinvent the wheel? The down vote system is something that has worked well over there IMO. I think it can be tweaked, but it is definitely something worth consideration.

    • #2534

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      @BeehiveUte brings up an interesting point of discussion. While I like UFN and am an active member there, this is not the same place nor is it intended to be. It should have it’s own personality and I want it to be more than just a forum.

      I don’t want to simply replicate what UFN does, though a standard great feature any board has is probably a good idea to implement, like say having an avatar.

      Not sure if I’m being clear enough, but the point is there may be cool features about UFN or even cougarboard which are similar here, but there will certainly be differences.

      • #2535

        Anonymous

        I like Utehub because it isn’t utefans.

      • #2539

        AZswayze
        Ute Fan
        @AZswayze

        For christsakes tony, nobody is trying to make it utefans. I will stop referencing them as some folks here are incredibly sensitive to that subject. I mention things I like from reddit, including their downvoting system, and nobody bats an eye. I’m just thinking of ways to help the site out, and if utefans currently does something better why would we not consider it? Just because it comes from utefans? C’mon now guys.

        • #2547

          Hockeybeard
          Ute Fan
          @hockeybeard

          The only reason I don’t want the system from utefans is because of the complete limiting factor – the poster cannot post over a certain amount. Instead, I like reddit’s functionality, where the post is auto-collapsed and you can move on with the discussion. If a troll makes a name for himself, then enough people recognize him and can downvote his posts so he never gets visualization, but the majority of discussion can continue unabated.

          • #2549

            AZswayze
            Ute Fan
            @AZswayze

            I love reddit’s system too, but it still allows trolls to start new threads which just clutters the board.

            • #2552

              Hockeybeard
              Ute Fan
              @hockeybeard

              Don’t know if its possible, but perhaps make a topic creation auto-mod, where a poster has reputation and must have a certain amount (above 0) to be able to post new topics.

              That way it doesn’t dissuade from posting replies, just new topics that would clutter the board.

              • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  Hockeybeard.
              • #2555

                Anonymous

                If you can’t create topics why not just have a moderator boot them? Hence you become de facto cougarboard.

                • #2566

                  AZswayze
                  Ute Fan
                  @AZswayze

                  I’ve already said this, I’m not a fan of giving that power to one person. Once enough people have spoken then somebody loses privileges.

          • #2554

            Anonymous

            Sounds like a good way to create cliques.

            • #2557

              Hockeybeard
              Ute Fan
              @hockeybeard

              Not really, unless its abused as a disagreement button. and even then, unless you are going out of your way to troll then you’re not going to get downvoted enough for it to affect you. Its a “community moderation” tool to combat trolls.

              • #2559

                Anonymous

                Ok so you want to limit content but don’t do it OVERTLY like cougarboard? I say trolls will exist and just ignore them. Moose is a troll yet people still replied to him despite his farewell post. Wait until he gets enough down votes or mod him out?

                • #2560

                  AZswayze
                  Ute Fan
                  @AZswayze

                  Yep, power to the people. What’s wrong with that?

                  • #2564

                    Anonymous

                    I prefer how America is run. A few people at the top controlling content and watching the fickle masses squirm.

                • #2561

                  Hockeybeard
                  Ute Fan
                  @hockeybeard

                  There is a difference between shadow-banning a user, and limiting an offending post. I, too, believe the best way to combat trolls is to simply ignore them – but that is not what 80% of the online community does. Each troll post still inevitably gains traction and will keep getting bumped up to the top of the category list. A solution like I’m suggesting would help keep the overall site discussion going the right way, instead of degenerating into useless trash or getting knocked off topic.

                  • #2581

                    Anonymous

                    I dont see the difference in a mod programming a content control and just booting the troll. Eventually both can and have been abused. I think it is easier to hold a mod accountable vs a whole community.

                    • #2589

                      Hockeybeard
                      Ute Fan
                      @hockeybeard

                      Valid point – but then you have to account for the lag effect of reversing the mod’s decisions or getting them removed from their position.

                      Its a discussion I think that is warranted. I’m in favor of a “upvote/downvote” system since I feel it helps give a sense of community when you are contributing to a thread – you feel bolstered by upvotes and want to continue posting. It also serves a function in moderation since it doesn’t tax a moderator to go through every post to figure out which ones to ban/delete – also leaves out the subjective decisions of one person and leaves it in the hands of the community as a whole.

        • #2572

          Tony
          Admin/Founder
          @admin

          Got you fired up there. Carry on. Great discussion.

          • #2574

            AZswayze
            Ute Fan
            @AZswayze

            I will quit with suggestions if it’s that big of a deal tony. If I overstepped my bounds I apologize, but I didn’t think making a few would rile some folks up so much. Jeesh.

            • #2582

              UteStuckInSeattle
              Ute Fan
              @utestuckinseattle

              Please continue to give suggestions, but please be prepared that some other site members may not feel the same way about all suggestions.

              The reality is that even though this is not UFN there are a lot of people who have come here from there and who will frequent both sites. Comparisons between the two are bound to be made.

              We don’t want to clone UFN and other fan sites but we don’t have to be against including something just because it exists on another fan site.

              We should gauge each feature based on it’s merits and contribution to THIS site.

            • #2584

              Wilson’s Mustache
              Ute Fan
              @sigmaute

              For what its worth I agree with you & didn’t see anything wrong with your suggestions.

              This site clearly is going to be different than UF.N, but that doesn’t mean it can’t borrow some of the things that have worked well over there or what has made UF.N so successful.

            • #2586

              Tony
              Admin/Founder
              @admin

              AZ I love the suggestions. You probably don’t realize how many requests I’ve fielded so my reaction was a bit to cover all of them, not just yours.

              I REALLY want all suggestions to keep coming because I want this site to be the best it can be.

              • #2592

                AZswayze
                Ute Fan
                @AZswayze

                Oh, I’ve seen the dozens and dozens of posts with suggestions, and can only imagine how many PM’s you’ve received. That’s why I’m blown away by this guy calling me out.

                • #2598

                  Tony
                  Admin/Founder
                  @admin

                  I’ve been pretty mentally frazzled, and the email problems really made it bad. With most of that fixed I can get on participating and tweaking the site with improvements.

          • #2595

            Samak
            Ute Fan
            @samak

            Trolls just want attention. If UFN’s system has taught us anything, the blue stars only encourage trolls to post more because it’s confirmation that they’re posts are striking a chord and getting to people.

            I never blue starred the Duckgrad types over there for that reason.

            I like Tony’s idea to keep things as positive as possible on this site.

            • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  Samak.
            • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  Samak.
            • #2599

              Tony
              Admin/Founder
              @admin

              the blue starts only encourage trolls to post more because it’s confirmation that they’re posts are striking a cord and getting to people.

              Wow hadn’t thought of that. Makes sense. They troll, get a bunch of blue stars, and feel like they’ve done their job.

              • #2605

                Anonymous

                Do not feed the trolls.

              • #2608

                Hockeybeard
                Ute Fan
                @hockeybeard

                That is why there needs to be a negative consequence to the downvote – i.e. hide the post (gray it out, collapse it, something that make it easy to skip without seeing it).

                • #2623

                  Anonymous

                  Sadist vs masochist? Trolls want attention.

              • #2630

                Homer Crimson
                Ute Fan
                @homercrimson

                If I find myself blue-starring a troll more than a few times, I just put them on ignore. Works great. There are folks on uf.n I’ve blue starred multiple times, but I choose not to block them because they have other, worthwhile input.

                Tony, this is a great start. The beauty of this being so new, is that you can experiment. I’d love to try the reddit system of downvoting. If you or others don’t like it, hey, just get rid of it. I know you’re herding cats right now, but don’t get hung up on changes being permanent, and don’t be afraid to try different approaches.

                • #2650

                  Hockeybeard
                  Ute Fan
                  @hockeybeard

                  This brings up the other aspect of an ignore feature in conjunction with the downvotes – have both and then its the best of both worlds.

    • #2580

      Samak
      Ute Fan
      @samak

      Trolls seem to thrive off any attention — whether it’s thumbs up or down. I agree with other posters that just ignoring or quickly banning is the best way to combat.

      • #2591

        Hockeybeard
        Ute Fan
        @hockeybeard

        I don’t disagree – it is the single best way to get trolls to go away. However, practically speaking, it is hard to do to coordinate an entire site’s worth of posters (668 and counting!) to not respond to a troll’s post. It also encourages trolls to get more and more daring/boisterous/offensive to get reactions out of people.

    • #2604

      execUTEioner
      Ute Fan
      @executeioner

      I would like a downvote option as well.

    • #2637

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      I’ve never used Reddit. I guess I’ll go take a look.

    • #2675

      Brettski
      Ute Fan
      @brettski

      That was a ridiculous read haha.

    • #2720

      DANgerous
      Ute Fan
      @dangerousute

      Ahhhhh. Our first Utehub fight.

    • #2737

      Utemachine
      Ute Fan
      @utemachine

      I like UFN and have been a member since 2003, however I think the Hub can be something for a broader audience of Ute fans. The blue star has bred an atmosphere of negativity. If it’s important enough to decent then take the time to write a post. The down vote serves a negative purpose and keeps lurkers, observers, and new members on the sidelines. If we want a different feel, encourage conversation, not discourage with a down vote. A down vote is a move that will irreparably change the feel and tone of a fresh new hub for fellow Utes.

    • #2740

      AZswayze
      Ute Fan
      @AZswayze

      What about a transparent downvote where everybody can see who downvotes others? Might keep some folks from being so liberal with the downvotes. I’m just trying to think of ways to keep trolls at bay without overloading mods, and move quality posts up.

      • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  AZswayze.
    • #2755

      Tacoma Ute
      Ute Fan
      @tacomaute

      I don’t know what to think. When I read posts outlining reasons not to have down votes I agree with the points being made. When I read posts in favor of having down votes I see their points as well.

      Tough call.

      • #2757

        Tony
        Admin/Founder
        @admin

        Just gave your comment a thumbs-up Tacoma. Good reasons on both sides. Perhaps the a factor will be IF the feature is even available or possible.

    • #2775

      GadValleyUte
      Ute Fan
      @maximumkungfu

      I’m kinda like @AZswayze. I only ever blue star trolls over on ufn and never just for for simply disagreeing with a post so I see his argument for the utility. However any system that can be abused will be abused so the trick is to figure out how to control trolls through some decentralized method while limiting/disincentivizing abuse?
      I like the idea of collapsing comments with enough “dislikes”
      I like the idea of limiting posts by folks who consistently make “disliked” comments
      I like the idea of having “dislikes” not be anonymous
      I like the idea of limiting the number of dislikes in a time period maybe x/day or week
      Perhaps instead of a dislike button what about a “troll” icon then it’s clear this isn’t just to show you disagree but an trolling control measure?

    • #2799

      JDub1942
      Ute Fan
      @jdub1942

      I think there have been a lot of good ideas here, the ones that make the most sense to me are:
      A) the reddit row vote system
      And
      B) transparency for up and down votes

      I know a lot of people still love UFN and want to use this place to add to that. And there are a lot of people who strongly dislike Utefans.net, but it seems to me that both groups should want this place to be different from what already there or else what’s the point?

    • #2805

      jrj84105
      Ute Fan
      @jrj84105

      Rivals board has non-anonymous up votes. It’s great and would work just as well for down votes I think

      • #2810

        RedLine
        Ute Fan
        @redline

        I like this idea. Would definitely bring some accountability to down voting.

        • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by  RedLine.
    • #2829

      Jumpmasterute
      Ute Fan
      @jumpmasterute

      In my eyes jrj84105 suggestion makes the most sense.

    • #2832

      SouthJordanUte
      Ute Fan
      @southjordanute

      Anyway to dislike this whole thread?

      • #2833

        UtahUteGuy
        Ute Fan
        @utahuteguy

        Yeah, this thread is depressing. 🙁

    • #2834

      Tony
      Admin/Founder
      @admin

      Anyway to dislike this whole thread?

      Haha.

      Actually the Like plugin is very old. It is SUPPOSED to show who liked, just like the suggestion. It’s not for some reason.

    BACK TO TOP

    You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

    Utah Utes Message Board Forums Ute Hub Site Comments and Suggestions Can we have downvotes (dislikes)?

    This topic contains 72 replies, has 22 voices, and was last updated by  Tony 3 years, 10 months ago.