Site-Wide Activity

I feel like this is a benefit to poo poo this early in the year.

Keeping things private isn’t necessarily sweeping it under the rug. The HC office isn’t going to fo aire the dirty laundry of everyone who violated the code but didn’t commit any crime.

In JR’S case, because there’s a legal filing of course its public.

I think BYU will be better in the long run with a new QB. They are lucky that they start with a very easy schedule, and the new QB can get acclimated. I suspect it will be Hillstead, and in the end, I think he will be more productive for BYU.

BYU does NOT handle the honor code the way it has in the past. Previously, you would be suspended for…[Read more]

Since the Davies suspension, BYU has made a concerted effort to handle honor code violations in private unless the violation is made public through some other means. I have heard that part of this shift in honor code enforcement has resulted in lighter consequences for athletes. In other words, they sweep what they can under the rug.

Of all the ways for the season to be easier for Utah, this one sucks the most. I am very much not a lawyer, and I’ve been trying to avoid touching this with a ten foot pole, but both outcomes appear to suck quite a bit.

Apparently lines up with their term schedule, so it would be a 1 term suspension

If you haven’t looked at their schedule, it’s very easy. All three non-con games should be cake, then they get Cincinnati, Arizona, UCF, and West Virginia. I’d be shocked if they lose more than one of those.

Even without Retzlaff, I like them to beat TCU at home. And who knows what we’ll get from Colorado.

I think they’re 7-5 at the worst.

Is there any precedent for a 7 game suspension?

In a 12-game season, 7 isn’t a round number (6 or 8 would be).

I’m just noticing that Utah is their 7th game. Seems like they’re going out of their way to suspend him for their most important game.

Is that to make sure he leaves? Or to make sure that the backups are 100% focused even if he stays…[Read more]

This is the key. Take a minute and look at the list of the top 25 Utah football recruits all time. Half you don’t remember because they left for some reason and/or simply didn’t see the field in any meaningful way. Then consider the list of Utah football players drafted by the NFL. Note pleanty of players that did not get attention when initially…[Read more]

I don’t understand why you’d be shocked, BYU his far more orthodox than they used to be and they uphold the honor code. A decade ago their BBall player got kicked out of school because of honor code violations. Ive seen nothing that suggests BYU would sweep it under the rug with the way the school has been run.

Had this been in the 1980’s, then sure.

Does Utah believe that Retzlaff worse than our QB2, or so we just not want the baggage that’ll inevitably follow him?

A 7 game suspension is nothing compared to jail time, which if you believe the victim in this case, he deserves. I’m actually shocked that he would receive any punishment from BYU. I thought for sure it would be swept under the rug. 7-5 sounds about right if he leaves, 9-3 if he stays.

I still laugh at fans getting frothy over a recruit signing (or not signing). How many times do I have to say it? HS recruiting doesn’t matter any more. No, not in the slightest.

From the Horses mouth.

“We are going to focus less and less on kids from HS and fill our immediate needs with players from the portal”. “High School players with fill depth gaps.”

There is no developing in the NIL era. The second that talent grows into NFL caliber type players, they will seek out better NIL deals that Utah can’t match. It’s a big reason why they lost some decent talent to BYU, Washington and Alabama in the previous portals – those schools all have more NIL resources than Utah.

The Utes will be able to…[Read more]

I mean, we’ve had two sht years and bringing in a brand new OC. you think high school kids are flocking in line to come to Utah? Naw, while I do like the guys we are recruiting, we are a developing school and going back to the way we do things. mold 3 star into NFL talent.

No? I think we can all agree that the 2024 season would have gone dramatically different for Utah if Rising didn’t get injured vs Baylor.

No coach is going to have a full and clear understanding of how things will go if they lose their best player.

If you want to be critical of Whitt over something, be critical of the fact he put all his eggs in…[Read more]

Right, so Whittingham had no idea what he was about to field. Do you understand how concerning that is if you believe it’s true?

What’s more we already aren’t competing on the field. Two and a half years of the worst football in decades and a middling recruiting class. There aren’t a lot of programs where the coach wouldn’t be on the chopping block at this point.