Frustrating that we arent getting a ton of credit for that win. Almost none nationally. That was a win over a top 20 caliber team in their building with one of the smartest matchup/schematic coaches in the country coming off a bye week. The wtf Stanford game is keeping their perception way down. Well below where their actual standing based off their entire satistical bodyof work places them. Not saying they deserve to be ranked top 20 by any means, but its arguably as tough of a win as…say…Baylor, who sits 3 spots behind UW in FPI and 9 spots behind is s/p (1 spot adv in sag), when you factor in their bye week its certainly close
Looking at a couple of computer rankings like Massey, Sagarin, and SP+, Utah’s strength of schedule is middle of the pack compared with the rest of top ten.
Utah doesn’t have a signature win, but overall their SOS is within reason and certainly better than even teams ranked above them. Utah has just played a bunch of teams hovering around .500. No Arkansas or Rutgers in conference play.
This is what make college footbal interesting, but also annoying. Quality losses, quality wins. What other sport is ever talked about in those terms?
Way too early but interesting…..Utah #10 in Sagarin Basketball ratings
There is often a complaint about the PAC 12 strength of schedule and it impacting our rankings. I thought I would compare the AP top 10 teams” strengths of schedules as rated by Sagarin and Massey and rank them 1 to 10.
Sagarin Massey
LSU 4 3
Alabama 9 8
Ohio St 2 4
Clemson 10 10
Penn St 5 5
Georgia 8 9
Oregon 3 2
Utah 6 6
Oklahoma 7 7
Florida 1 1
Of one loss teams, both systems rank strongest schedules as follows: Oregon, Utah, Georgia and Oklahoma.
For interest:
My kids were taking some college prep stuff recently and we did some study with analogies.
I used the points awarded in each ranking to see the difference between strength of schedules to create these analogies:
Massey
Alabama is to Utah as SMU is to Alabama
Alabama is to Oregon as Temple is to Alabama
Sagarin
Alabama is to Utah as Middle Tennessee is to Alabama
Alabama is to Oregon as San Jose State is to Oregon
but s&p, Sagarin, and Vegas all give us about a 4 point edge. Utah is 16 spots higher in massey composite. So, essentially, their argument was math based while using the OUTLIER as evidence.. just….lol
I realize this is about as serious as the preseason rankings, but it something else to discuss.
Sagarin has us at 22nd with an 81.15 value. He has our first opponent at 69.59 and even with the home field advantage bonus that gives us a projected 9+ point win.
Not suggesting you go out and put any M&M on this, but just one more indication that the Cougarboard people may be a tad delusional.